– The book is rightly subtitled "New Labour, Human Rights and the Rule of Law" and describes, with examples, the erosion of our civil liberties since 1997. It starts ominously with this statement: "we live in a society where the police have more power, where we are watched and monitored more closely and more often, and in which our ability to speak out and protest is subject to more and more restraints". A damning indictment of New Labour, many may feel, if ever there was one. Ewing does say that many people do not share his views although "at best they may share the concerns" and that really sums up the worth of the work - it's a collection of statements on areas of the law which affect the direct relationship between the State and its people with worrying conclusions. Ewing is clearly trying to douse the "lack of liberties" fire which still seems to be out of control and it's a useful commentary on the parlous state of today's "rights" which will be viewed with interest in a couple of years' time (we hope).
Bonfire of the Liberties
«...the definitive text on Labour government's attack on liberty and rights...»
Henry Porter, Liberty cetral Blog, Guardian.co.uk
This provocative book confronts the corrosion of civil liberties under successive New Labour governments since 1997. It argues that the last decade has seen a wholesale failure of constitutional principle and exposed the futility of depending on legal rights to restrict the power of executive government. Les mer
Logg inn for å se din bonus
be adequately protected.
Relying on extensive new research of inaccessible sources, the book examines the major battlegrounds over civil liberties under New Labour, including the growth and abuse of police power, state surveillance and counter-terrorist measures. It unfolds a compelling narrative of the major battles fought before Parliament and in the courts, and attacks the failure of the political and legal systems to offer protection to those suffering abuses of their civil liberty at the hands of an aggressive
Executive. In doing so, it offers a definitive account of the struggle for civil liberty in modern Britain, and a controversial argument for the reforms necessary to contain executive power.
Medlemsvurdering:
The book is rightly subtitled "New Labour, Human Rights and the Rule of Law" and describes, with examples, the erosion of our civil liberties since 1997. It starts ominously with this statement: "we live in a society where the police have more power, where we are watched and monitored more closely and more often, and in which our ability to speak out and protest is subject to more and more restraints". A damning indictment of New Labour, many may feel, if ever there was one. Ewing does say that many people do not share his views although "at best they may share the concerns" and that really sums up the worth of the work - it's a collection of statements on areas of the law which affect the direct relationship between the State and its people with worrying conclusions. Ewing is clearly trying to douse the "lack of liberties" fire which still seems to be out of control and it's a useful commentary on the parlous state of today's "rights" which will be viewed with interest in a couple of years' time (we hope).PhillipTaylor
Detaljer
- Forlag
- Oxford University Press
- Innbinding
- Paperback
- Språk
- Engelsk
- ISBN
- 9780199584789
- Utgivelsesår
- 2010
- Format
- 23 x 16 cm
Anmeldelser
«...the definitive text on Labour government's attack on liberty and rights...»
Henry Porter, Liberty cetral Blog, Guardian.co.uk
«...As a handy catalogue of the duplicity and chicanery displayed by this administration it is excellent... the book's greatest achievement is to translate often dense legal argument into something slightly more palatable to the general reader...»
Paddy McGuffin, Morning Star
«The aims of this book appear to be twofold. First it provides a much needed documentation of the continuing 'erosion of civil liberties' (p.vii) that occurred under the previous Labour Government...Secondly, building upon this analysis, Professor Ewing aims to provide a politics-based solution to the deficiencies of the HRA. First and foremost, this book is about a contradiction...Professor Ewing powerfully demonstrates how empty the culture of liberty rhetoric has been, and shows that there has been a contradiction at the heart of Government.»
Matthew Burton, Birmingham Law School, Human Rights Law Review 11:2
«Britain is undoubtedly a much better, informed and relaxed place to live than 13 years ago; one would really need to be a hidebound reactionary not to recognise this. On civil liberties, however Labour urgently needs to restore its credentials. It could make a start by having a long discussion with Professor Ewing and other critics about finding the right balance between liberties and effective protection against terrorism.»
David Winnick, Tribune
«Keith Ewing has written an excellent and damning indictment of New Labour's record on human rights and the rule of law, marshalling his evidence with ease and great narrative power. It is a real tour de force.»
James A. Grant, University of Oxford, The Modern Law Review
«It's very readable and something which all MPs ought to read, especially the new intake from 6th May 2010. Probably the single most important theme is the erosion of individual rights by the state and Ewing backs up each topical issue with breathless detail to justify the assertions made...a useful commentary on the parlous state of today's 'rights'»
Phillip Taylor MBE and Elizabeth Taylor, Richmond Green Chambers
«...core content of considerable value... an excellent critique»
Geoffrey Robertson, New Statesman.com